General Guide for Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion (3)

  • Hyo-Jung Kwon, Yong-Suk Kim*
    Department of Acupuncture & Moxibustion, (Brain & Neurological Disorders and Pain), Kangnam Korean Hospital, Kyung Hee University, Seoul, Korea
  • Open Journal of Immunology, 2015, 5, 90-103

4. Diagnosis Method

The scope of Saam acupuncture can be extensive because of its diverse laws, such as the promotion and inhibi-tion (control) cycles among the Five Elements and their corresponding Meridians. A Meridian consists of three parts; that are, upper extremity or lower extremity, more or less of Yin and Yang, and one of Six Organs (Zangs including Pericardium) and Six Bowels (Fus). A total of 24 deficiency and excess symptoms exist across the Six Organs and Six Bowels, but theories related to these symptoms are too arbitrary to assist in making a diagnosis.
Although there are currently many clinical books on Saam acupuncture in Korea, a definitive general standard for the selection of symptom patterns has not yet been established. The general use of Saam acupuncture has previously been discussed in 1985 [20]. The method can be used mainly from a theoretical viewpoint of the Organs, etiology of disease, as well as the more or less of the three Yang and three Yin. For example, in the case of knee pain, one can use Liver-tonification (mostly deficiency condition) because, according to the theory of the Organs, the Liver controls the muscles and joints. Secondly, in the case of headache due to increasing Liver-Yang, one may use Liver-sedation (mostly excess condition) given the etiology of the disease. Furthermore, in the case of backache due to dampness, we can use either Spleen-sedation (excess condition) to sedate dampness or Yangming-tonification (deficiency of Large Intestine or Stomach) to tonify dryness from the principle of the
more or less of the three Yang and three Yin.
The above three viewpoints cannot fully explain Saam acupuncture, so a common differential diagnosis shared by many acupuncturists needs to be determined. Lee [21] was the first to propose a differential diagnosis of deficiency and excess by simultaneously comparing the six pulses of both wrists in the 1960s. However, his diagnosis was only focused on deficiency and excess, neglecting coldness and heat. Although he said that irregular forms of treatments were the manifestation of subtle changes in diseases, signs and symptoms are needed to support his assertions. Lee’s comparative pulse diagnosis is very original in that it attempted to determine different symptoms, but a diagnosis made only using the pulse method is difficult. Comparative pulse diagnosis can therefore be an important guide in using Saam acupuncture, despite its weakness.
Kim [22] stated that he proposed the diagnosis method called “Saam Five Elements acupuncture of disease symptoms,” which differentiates symptoms by simultaneously comparing the pulse, as he found that the original Saam acupuncture could not cope with changes in diseases. He asserted that a floating pulse showed Yang excess and Yin deficiency, while a deep pulse demonstrated Yin excess and Yang deficiency on the basis that the medial pulse is neither floating nor deep, and is the manifestation of health. Kim also proposed, from his clinical experience, that more focus needs to be placed on the symptoms of coldness and heat rather than the symptoms of deficiency and excess when differentiating these two symptom types. This can be achieved by comparing both the right and the left Guan pulses. If the right Guan pulse is weaker than the left the symptom is related to coldness and heat, while if the left Guan pulse is weaker than the right Guan pulse the symptom is related to either deficiency or excess. For example, looking at the symptom of either coldness or heat, if the pulse is floating,
the main symptom is Yang excess and Yin deficiency. The treatment is then to first tonify the fire within the Yin Meridian and then to sedate the coldness within the Yang Meridian. In the heat symptom, if the pulse is deep, the main symptom is Yin excess and Yang deficiency. The treatment is to first tonify the coldness within the Yang Meridian and then to sedate the heat within the Yin Meridian.
The method used by Kim is more detailed than that of Lee, in that Kim used differentiation of coldness & heat symptom type and deficiency & excess symptom type, and set the criterion for Yin-Yang balance by standardizing medial pulse. Kim’s theory is still contentious and not fully accepted as a standard of general treatment as it is difficult to decide differential symptoms by pulse diagnosis only. The merit of Kim’s treatment is that it contributed greatly to the objective use of Saam acupuncture [7].
Seem [11] also believes that treatments using the four-needle technique are very powerful, and should only be pursued when a strong energetic manipulation is required, and only when one is certain of the primary diagnosis of the affected Five Elements or Phases. This recommendation is because the four-needle technique tonifies twice, then sedates twice, leading to a very concentrated tonifying or sedating action on the affected Five Elements and Meridian. If one is not certain of the primary affected Element, it is far more conservative to use more gentle tonification and sedation acupoints.
Generally speaking, Saam acupuncture primarily focuses on deficiency and excess symptoms rather than coldness and heat symptoms, although the relationship between the deficiency and excess symptom type and coldness and heat symptom type needs to be studied in detail in order to create reasonable guidelines for effective treatments. As there are many different ways to select Five Shu points from the various opinions concerning Five Element acupuncture, we need to determine detailed guidelines for patterns of symptoms in the future.

5. Practice of Saam Acupuncture

Saam acupuncture is primarily focused on Five Shu points, which contradicts other acupuncture methods. For example, backache can be caused by disturbances of the Bladder Meridian, so one can use tonification or sedation of the Bladder Meridian depending upon deficiency or excess. Backache can also be caused by weakness of the Kidney Meridian, which one can then treat by using tonification of the Kidney Meridian. Finally, backache is caused due to excessive dampness of the Spleen, which can be diagnosed in obese people. One can then use tonification of the dry Large Intestine Meridian or Stomach Meridian in order to dry out dampness. Sedation of the damp Spleen Meridian can also be used on rare occasion. The selection of tonification or sedation depends wholly upon the diagnosing practitioner.
Backache is generally associated with Kidney or Bladder functions. The Governor vessel and Gallbladder Meridian, with little connection to other Meridians, can also be involved in backache. Saam acupuncture treats backache using a novel approach. It relates backache to the malfunction of connected Organs (i.e. the Bladder, Kidney and Gall Bladder) to the imbalance of Yin and Yang (Six Qi) while primarily using Five Shu acupuncture points. It is a wonder how the combination of the acupoints distal to the painful region and located beneath the elbow and knee joints can treat diseases such as backache, shoulder pain, and whatnot. This wonder may be understood using Yun-Tao-Mao’s neurobiological fact: as the limbs below the elbows and knees occupy larger areas in the sensory gyrus in the brain and the acupoints below the elbows and knees contain more sensory receptors, needling stimulation to these points may induce a greater reaction and activity in the brain. This principle clearly supports the concept of using certain acupoints below the elbows and knees, such as the Five Shu points, as diagnosis and treatment points during acupuncture treatment. 
In cases of interruption, acupoints are selected based on local and special effects in correlation with efficacy. Five Shu points are selected for either deficiency or excess conditions to tonify or sedate in cases of imbalance. Overall acupuncture treatment method that covers the treatment of interruptions and imbalances of illnesses should be selected. For instance, more effective treatment result may be achieved if we use Saam acupuncture as a “root treatment” to correct imbalances but then combine it with Meridian style acupuncture, channel therapy acupuncture (which uses local and distal acupoints), special acupuncture points, or symptomatic treatment Meridian therapy, as “branch treatments”, to correct interruptions in proper stimulation technique.
The original form of Saam acupuncture can be used from the perspective of the Five Organs, disease etiology, imbalanced Yin and Yang, the mind-only theory and the comparing-pulse diagnoses such as Lee [21] and Kim [22]

[1] Yin, C., Park, H.J., Chae, Y., Ha, E., Park, H.K., Lee, H.S., et al. (2007) Korean Acupuncture: The Individualized and Practical Acupuncture. Neurological Research, 29, 10-15.
[2] Kim, D.-H. and Kim, J.-H. (1993) The Literary Study on the Written Date of and the Background of Sa-Ahm’s 5 Element Acupuncture Method. Kyungwon University, Kyungki.
[3] Yin, C.-S. Chae, Y.-B., Koh, H.-G., Lee, H.-J., Chun, S.-I., et al. (2006) Constitutionally Individualized and Practically Integrated Characteristics of Korean Acupuncture. Korean Journal of Acupuncture, 23, 19-28.
[4] Ahn, C.B., Jang, K.J., Yoon, H.M., Kim, C.H., Min, Y.K., Song, C.H., et al. (2010) Sa-Ahm Five Element Acupuncture. Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies, 3, 203-213.
[5] Lee, T.H. (1996) Essentials of Saam’s Acupuncture Theory. Haenglim Publishing, Seoul.
[6] Jeremy, R. (2004) Acupuncture Point Combination. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh.
[7] Wu, G. (1980) Gatherings from Eminent Acupuncturists-Zhen Jiu Ju Ying. Shinmunfung Publisher, Taipei.
[8] Heng-pa (1975) The Essence of Sa-Ahm’s Acupuncture. Heng-Lim Publisher, Seoul.
[9] Hicks, A.H.J. and Mole, P. (2005) Five Element Constitutional Acupuncture. hurchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, 383-384.
[10] Zhang, Y. (1977) Huang-Ti Nei-Ching Su-Men Ling-Shu Ji-Zhu He-Pian. Tai-Lian Guo-Feng Chu-Ban She, Taipei.
[11] Ahn, C.B., Jang, K.J., Yoon, H.M., Kim, C.H., Min, Y.K., Song, C.H., et al. (2009) A Study of the Sa-Ahm Five Element Acupuncture Theory. Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies, 2, 309-320.
[12] Maciocia, G. (2005) The Foundation of Chinese Medicine. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh.
[13] Ma, Y. and Cho, Z. (2005) Biomedical Acupuncture for Pain Management. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh.
[14] Seem, M.D. (1991) Acupuncture Energetics. Healing Arts Press, Rochester.
[15] Chang, S. (1912) Chiao-cheng t’u-chu pa-shih-i Nan-Ching. Hung-pao chai shu-chu, Taipei, 6-11.
[16] Unschuld, P.U. (1986) Nan-Ching—The Classic of Difficult Issues. University of California Press, Oakland, 474-617.
[17] Lee, I. (2007) A Study on the Basic Forms and Principles of Saam’s 5 Phase of Acupuncture Method. Journal of the Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society, 1, 19-51.
[18] Kim, H.G. (1992) Handbook of Saam Acupuncture. Shinnongbaekcho Press, Seoul.
[19] Kim, D. (2002) Reviewed Sa-Ahm’s Acupuncture Treatment with Graphs. So-Gang Pub, Busan.
[20] Ahn, C.B. and Choi, D.Y. (1986) Theoretical Study on Five Element Acupuncture. Dongguk Journal, 5, 287-309.
[21] Lee, J.W. (1958) The Secret of Saam’s Acupuncture Based on Yin-Yang and Five Elements. Institute for Studying Five Element Acupuncture, Busan.
[22] Kim, D.P. (1972) Saam’s Five Element Acupuncture and Its Usages. The Journal of the Korean Oriental Medical Society, Winter Issue, 122-123.
[23] Song, M.S., Kim, Y.H., Jang, S.G., Kim, J.H., Yim, Y.K., Kang, J.H., et al. (2003) Clinical Comparison Studies on 20 Cases of Stroke Patients with Dysarthria by Sa-Am and General Acupuncture. Journal of the Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society, 20, 161-167.
[24] Kim, J.H., Park, E.J., Park, C.H., Cho, M.R., Ryu, C.R. and Chae, W.S. (2002) Comparison of the Improvement of Back Pain and Sciatica between Common Acupuncture Treatment Group and Common Acupuncture with Shin Jong Gyuk of Ohaeng Acupuncture Treatment Group. Journal of the Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society, 19, 84-91.
[25] Hwang, D.S., Kim, H.K., Seo, J.C., Shin, I.H., Kim, D.H. and Kim, Y.S. (2011) Sympathomodulatory Effects of Saam Acupuncture on Heart Rate Variability in Night-Shift-Working Nurses. Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 19, S33-S40.
[26] Kuon, D.W. (1965) A Study of Constitution-Acupuncture. Journal of the International Congress of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, 10, 149-167.
[27] Kim, J.K. (2011) Clinical Opinion of Taegeuk Acupuncture Treatment by Sasang (4-Type) Constitutional Medicine. Journal of the Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society, 28, 69-73.
[28] Kim, N.S., Kim, S.J., Ryu, H.J., Nam, S.S. and Kim, Y.S. (2012) Effects of Taegeuk Acupuncture on the Autonomic Nervous System by Analyzing Heart Rate Variability in Soyangin. Journal of the Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society, 29, 81-88.